Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

entry 5 Jul 2012, 19:59
Safety cars and full course caution periods have been part of the motor racing scene for some while now and have been a good idea. You've only got to have been around in the 60's, 70's and 80's and watched Formula One and Sports Car races to realise that they were definitely needed (as was the waving of a red flag to stop the race!). The trouble is now though, it seems that the race director can't wait to utilise them. It almost seems like they've paid for them so they might as well use them.

I watch as much as I can on the BBC, Sky, Itv, Eurosport, MOTORS TV and anywhere else I can see motor racing, notwithstanding the needs of my wife and daughters TV viewing. It is really apparant that the Americans have fully embraced the concept as NASCAR Nationwide, ALMS and GrandAm are rife with them. I heard on a Radio Le Mans podcast from their American correspondant Declan Brendan, that NASCAR like breaking up the races with full course cautions because the NASCAR crowd can't understand a race without them and that they like the field closed up all the time. It makes for the traditional crash, bang, wallop finish. Or is it all just contrived and an excuse? The same can be said of the sprint races in the American Le Mans Series as the safety car comes out, picks up the leader, the cars line up, the prototypes pit first, the GTs second, and once that has all been done, racing finally gets underway again, normally after an advert break or two. And what's with the wave round to get back on the lead lap? Where did that nutty idea come from?

Now even Formula One is getting in on the act as seen in Valencia with the cars lined up and the backmarkers waved through to get them out of the way and at the back of the field. Really? So now we have a train of cars travelling slowly behind a safety car and some others "bombing round" to catch up with the train. Hardly a "safety" moment surely? In the recent GrandAm race at Watkins Glen the Suntrust No10 DP lost a bit of bodywork off the nearside rear at the start in a bit of "argy-bargy" after a safety car period but, all the field went past it. Did a marshall run out and pick it up before the field came round again? No, they had another full course yellow. Blooming heck. I mean the fastest DP was lapping at 1m 41s or so. Surely waved yellow flags would have done the business?

Safety cars and full course cautions have become a growth business and I think they need to be reined in to let the motor racing become racing again.

« Next Oldest · Nick49's Blog · Next Newest »

Comments

post 6 Jul 2012, 07:34
Comment #1


Slothead
****

Group: Members
Posts: 174
Joined: 30-December 10
From: Horndean
Member No.: 16,945



Yes Nick I agree, my experience in live and TV racing is far less than yours, but I was a bit non plused and miffed by the Valencia episode. It is difficult to argue against something that claims to improve safety, to do so one should provide an alternative. My suggestion is really targeted at F1, but it would probably apply elsewhere.

In most potential safety car circumstances apply a rigorous speed limit and yellow flag regs just to the part of the circuit affected, racing would continue everywhere else, when I say speed limit I mean pit lane speeds or less. These days cars, teams, drivers and officials seem to have no difficulty in knowing the parameters being applied to each part of the track and applying sanctions for transgressing.

Why should an incident in a small part of the circuit have to apply a blanket safety car to the entire race?


--------------------
If I can't work it out, it must need common sense.
Go to the top of the page
post 6 Jul 2012, 18:30
Comment #2


Trackhead
*******

Group: Members
Posts: 881
Joined: 15-June 05
From: Hampshire, UK
Member No.: 2,497



Yes that's it exactly.
Go to the top of the page

 
« Next Oldest · Nick49's Blog · Next Newest »
 
SMTWTFS
1
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30

Random Album Image
tn_gallery_2497_355_60994.jpg




My Gallery Albums