SlotForum banner
1 - 3 of 3 Posts

· Premium Member
Joined
·
5,614 Posts
I do not wish to criticize this wonderful effort by Monogram, but I wish that they would have done a bit of a better job on them and refer you to this thread. One may argue on small details but the pictures show the basic flaws, especially on the tail design of both cars.
Otherwise, congrats to Revellogram for doing a great job.
Regards,

Philippe
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
5,614 Posts
QUOTE So how long before Patto has 'Lil' B*st*rd' decals a la James Dean?

OK, I guess I will have to elaborate here.
The first of the two Monogram cars is of a 1954 550 "high-tail" version, not of the 1955 production 550A Spyder. Two vastly different cars. The James Dean car is a 1955 550A Spyder and has a completely different, if similar, body, see below.
The main problem seen in the picture of the Monogram car is that the fins are angled OPPOSITE to that of the real thing, and are angular instead of rounded. Also the nose configuration is pure fantasy and hardly related to the real thing. In this case, see the 1/43rd Solido die-cast "100 series" model for much greater accuracy.

The second car (with spats on the rear wheels) appears to be a 1955 production car but again, from the picture, its wheels are the wrong type and it looks like it was crashed and poorly repaired in the rear end, and may be that is what they copied.... Problem is that the lines are far off that of the real thing as can be seen from many contemporary and today's pictures. As an example, here are some pics of my own car (identical in every respect to James Dean's car), the world's most original surviving 550: it has never even been repainted since new, please compare the body lines of this absolutely stock, unmodified 1955 550A:





And this are pics of the Anni-Mini models, far more accurate:




Also look at the wheels...

Again, this won't stop me from buying the Monogram models especially at their very attractive Chinese price, but I wish that they would have done as good of a job as they did on the NSU and all the American issues, save for the wheels on the Cobra Daytona that are vastly too large in diameter. I am thus a bit disappointed, but not detered.
Nothing is perfect in life...


Regards,

Doc Pea
(Never HapPea)
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
5,614 Posts
QUOTE 13Davek has pictures of a very different car to the ones you have just posted TSFR, with a nose and fins which look just like the Revell. Also YOU have posted a pic of a racing porsche at the bottom of the first page with the taller squarer fins. These racing versions have very different noses and fins to the pics you posted here and the pics of models in your first post in the other thread. Posting pics of a completely different car is just confusing the issue.

Not if you actually READ the message:

QUOTE The first of the two Monogram cars is of a 1954 550 "high-tail" version, not of the 1955 production 550A Spyder. Two vastly different cars. The James Dean car is a 1955 550A Spyder and has a completely different, if similar, body, see below... The second car (with spats on the rear wheels) appears to be a 1955 production car...

I am sorry that you are so confused. And I guess it is well enough, and Monogram could have produced a 1.5-liter Borgward and dubbed it a Porsche 550 and it appears that many here would have never even grasped the difference.
Regards,

Doc Pea
 
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top