Woah there. I think you are really reaching there, and it is also a bit condescending.
The reason that you do not get 'the problem' is that there isn't one as far as I can see. Some people like something, some don't, big woop. The 'problem' only comes because you asign 'flaws' to those who don't agree with you.
I think the DW12 is extremely ugly. This does mean anything beyond the fact I think it extremely ugly. There is nothing else 'clear' in the statements of those who think the same unless they choose to explicitly add them.
I'm a realist. Advances in aero mean that cars are going to look very different to their clean-lined predecessors. Some look good, IMHO, some look terrible, IMHO, and there is nothing more to it than that, and certainly nothing as sick as what you prescribe.